‘music’ ~ mousikē /MATHIESEN 1/

Zambelis Spyros

Παλαιό Μέλος
The modern Western concept of ‘music’ differs from the ancient Greek concept of mousikē. For the Greeks, music was both an art and a subject of scientific and philosophical inquiry. It could provide relaxation and entertainment as well as playing a central role in civic and religious life. In the second book of his treatise On Music (Peri mousikēs), Aristides Quintilianus (fl late 3rd century – 4th century ce) remarks on the pervasiveness of music:
There is certainly no action among men that is carried out without music. Sacred hymns and offerings are adorned with music, specific feasts and the festal assemblies of cities exult in it, wars and marches are both aroused and composed through music. It makes sailing and rowing and the most difficult of the handicrafts not burdensome by providing an encouragement for the work.
Recognizing its broad role, he identified (i.5) theoretical and practical subclasses of mousikē, each consisting of various subjects and disciplines (for a diagram see Aristides Quintilianus), ranging from the narrowly technical to the broadly philosophical.
Centuries earlier, such conceptual breadth had enabled Plato, in the Timaeus, to employ music as a cosmological paradigm, but he was also concerned in the Republic and the Laws with practical issues such as the influence of music on behaviour and the types of music that should be allowed in an enlightened civilization. Likewise, in the eighth book of the Politics, Aristotle elaborated on the educational function of music and pointed out its effect in the development of character. The pure phenomena of music attracted the interest of various early philosophical schools, especially the Pythagoreans and another group that came to be known as ‘Harmonicists’ (harmonikoi); within this scientific tradition Aristotle's famous disciple Aristoxenus, in a treatise transmitted under the title Harmonic Elements (Harmonika stoicheia), developed a highly sophisticated system for analysing musical phenomena.
By the 2nd century bce the earlier practical, scientific and philosophical traditions of music were beginning to fade. Even so, for the next several centuries, authors of late antiquity would continue to write treatments of the subject in Greek and Latin. Byzantine and Arabic scholars remained interested in ancient Greek music theory well into the second millennium of the present era, but in the West the music and its theory began to be forgotten after the time of Boethius and Cassiodorus, leaving only faint and imperfect echoes in later treatises.
When Renaissance humanists began to rediscover the cultural treasures of antiquity, they were intrigued by the legendary powers and quality of the music of ancient Greece but were frustrated by the difficulties in recapturing the music of an earlier time. The humanists were also hampered by the absence of notated pieces of music, by incomplete or imperfect manuscripts of texts they wished to read, and by a limited knowledge and understanding of other valuable pieces of evidence, iconographic and archaeological.
In the 17th and 18th centuries more of the theoretical and literary sources that speak of ancient Greek music began to circulate in published form. The most important of these publications was Marcus Meibom's Antiquae musicae auctores septem (Amsterdam, 1652), an edition of seven Greek treatises with parallel translations in Latin, a book of some 800 pages. This edition complemented Athanasius Kircher's famous Musurgia universalis (Rome, 1650), and both influenced John Wallis's 1682 and 1699 editions of two treatises Meibom had not included in his collection: the Harmonics (Harmonika) of Ptolemy and Porphyry's commentary on it. These substantial technical publications provided 18th-century scholars with a wealth of material that appealed to their antiquarian and historical interests, while also supplying evidence for arguments about the purpose and meaning of music. L.C. Mizler von Kolof and Johann Mattheson, for example, drew on ostensibly divergent trends in the Greek sources to bolster their own aesthetic differences, while historians such as F.W. Marpurg, G.B. Martini and Sir John Hawkins tried to develop coherent historical surveys.
Greater control of the literary sources was accomplished during the 19th century, and the discovery of a fair amount of music notated on stone and papyrus and in manuscripts excited renewed debate about the value of ancient Greek music and the prospect of understanding its legendary powers. With the publication during the 20th century of new critical texts, catalogues of manuscripts, and an enormous quantity of critical studies, scholars continued to build on these earlier foundations.
It is impossible to reconstruct every detail of the music of the ancient Greeks, but a broad range of source material provides a good deal of information. Four principal types of sources are available for the study of ancient Greek music and music theory: literature, works of graphic or plastic art, archaeological remains, and notated pieces of music. No single class of source material is sufficient to present a complete picture; each gains in relation to the others, and only when viewed as a complex do they begin to reveal the richness and vitality of mousikē.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

προς επεξεργασία :

‘music’
mousikē
On Music (Peri mousikēs), Aristides Quintilianus (fl late 3rd century – 4th century ce)
diagram, Aristides Quintilianus
Plato, in the Timaeus
Republic
Laws
Politics, Aristotle
educational function of music
Pythagoreans
‘Harmonicists’ (harmonikoi)
Aristoxenus
Harmonic Elements (Harmonika stoicheia)
Latin. Byzantine and Arabic scholars
Boethius
Cassiodorus
Renaissance humanists
Marcus Meibom's Antiquae musicae auctores septem (Amsterdam, 1652)
Athanasius Kircher's famous Musurgia universalis (Rome, 1650),
John Wallis's 1682
the Harmonics (Harmonika) of Ptolemy and Porphyry's commentary
L.C. Mizler von Kolof
Johann Mattheson,
F.W. Marpurg
G.B. Martini
Sir John Hawkins
 

Zambelis Spyros

Παλαιό Μέλος
Musical allusions and general descriptions appear in the Iliad and the Odyssey, in lyric poetry and in dramatic works of ancient Greece. As nearly all this literature was sung, danced, and accompanied by musical instruments, the literature itself is a part of the musical heritage of Greece. In addition, general descriptions of music and music theory abound in philosophy, collections of anecdotes, and similar types of literature. Plato, Aristotle, Plutarch, Sextus Empiricus and other representatives of various philosophical schools wrote in detail about the use, character and value of music. Historical, anecdotal and lexicographical works such as Pausanias's Description of Greece (Graeciae descriptio), Athenaeus's Sophists at Dinner (Deipnosophistai), Plutarch's Table-Talk (Sumposiaka problēmata), Photius's Bibliotheca, the Etymologicon magnum, the Suda and Pollux's Onomasticon contain valuable detail on such matters as construction and use of musical instruments, types of music and occasions when it might be used, and the effect of music on behaviour.
Technical or systematic works that treat the theory of ancient Greek music extend over a wide period from the 4th century bce to the 4th century ce, or even later if works written in late antiquity and the Middle Ages in Latin, Greek and Arabic are included. These later works, however, should be considered representatives of the transmission of ancient Greek music theory rather than parts of its primary corpus. Of the earlier treatises, some are technical manuals that provide valuable detail about the Greeks’ musical system, including notation, the function and placement of notes in a scale, characteristics of consonance and dissonance, rhythm, and types of musical composition. This group includes the Division of the Canon (Katatomē kanonos; sometimes erroneously attributed to Euclid); Cleonides, Harmonic Introduction (Eisagōgē harmonikē); Nicomachus of Gerasa, Manual of Harmonics (Harmonikon engcheiridion); Theon of Smyrna, On Mathematics Useful for the Understanding of Plato (Tōn kata to mathēmatikon chrēsimōn eis tēn Platōnos anagnōsin); Gaudentius, Harmonic Introduction (Harmonikē eisaōgē); Alypius, Introduction to Music (Eisagōgē mousikē); Bacchius, Introduction to the Art of Music (Eisagōgē technēs mousikēs); Dionysius, Introduction to the Art of Music (Eisagōgē technēs mousikēs); the so-called Bellermann's Anonymous; and others. By contrast, some of the treatises are long and elaborate books showing the way in which mousikē reveals universal patterns of order, thereby leading to the highest levels of knowledge and understanding. Authors of these longer books – Aristoxenus, Ptolemy, Porphyry and Aristides Quintilianus – were in some cases well-known figures of antiquity.
Literary sources supply much information about music, but they are not especially useful in determining how music sounded or was performed. Answers to these questions must be addressed through the music itself, musical instruments, and iconographic sources illustrating instruments, manner of performance (to some degree), and social contexts in which music was used, ranging from music lessons to processions, banquets, the theatre and festivals. Various types of lyre, the aulos and percussion instruments are seen being tuned and played (alone or in ensemble) or sometimes simply hanging on a wall. Statuary, gemstones and coins exhibiting instruments in three dimensions or low relief help clarify the perspective shown in paintings. Remains of musical instruments discovered in archaeological excavations can be of incalculable value in making reconstructions of instruments; such reconstructions help to bridge the gap between performances captured by the graphic or plastic artists and the sound of the music itself.
A final source of inestimable importance is the ever-growing body of musical fragments that appear in manuscripts and on stone and papyrus. At least six important new pieces, including a second fragment from a work of Euripides, came to light during the last 30 years of the 20th century. Although the precise number varies according to the differing assessments of scholars, more than 40 ‘fragments’ dating from between the 3rd century bce and the 4th century ce are now known (see §8 below). Some of these pieces are indeed quite fragmentary, but others are complete or nearly complete compositions. Theoretical sources have made it possible to transcribe these pieces with reasonable certainty.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Λέξεις κλειδιά

Iliad
Odyssey
lyric poetry
dramatic works
sung
danced
accompanied by musical instruments
Plato
Aristotle
Plutarch
Sextus Empiricus
Pausanias's Description of Greece (Graeciae descriptio)
Athenaeus's Sophists at Dinner (Deipnosophistai)
Plutarch's Table-Talk (Sumposiaka problēmata),
Photius's Bibliotheca,
Suda
Pollux's Onomasticon
Division of the Canon (Katatomē kanonos, Euclid)
Cleonides,Harmonic Introduction (Eisagōgē harmonikē)
Nicomachus of Gerasa, Manual of Harmonics (Harmonikon engcheiridion)
Theon of Smyrna, On Mathematics Useful for the Understanding of Plato (Tōn kata to mathēmatikon chrēsimōn eis tēn Platōnos anagnōsin
Gaudentius, Harmonic Introduction (Harmonikē eisaōgē)
Alypius, Introduction to Music (Eisagōgē mousikē)
Bacchius, Introduction to the Art of Music (Eisagōgē technēs mousikēs)
Dionysius, Introduction to the Art of Music (Eisagōgē technēs mousikēs)
Bellermann's Anonymous
Aristoxenus
Ptolemy
Porphyry
Aristides Quintilianus
musical instruments
iconographic sources illustrating instruments
performance
processions
banquets
theatre
festivals
lyre
aulos
percussion instruments
Statuary
gemstones
relief
making reconstructions of instruments
graphic or plastic artists
musical fragments
manuscripts
second fragment from a work of Euripides,
40 ‘fragments’
 

Zambelis Spyros

Παλαιό Μέλος
The broad subject of ‘ancient Greek music and music theory’ requires some definition of region and chronological limits. Cycladic sculpture of musicians, belonging to the period 2700–2100 bce, has been discovered on the islands of Keros, Thera and Naxos; frescoes from the Minoan period (c2300–1100 bce) survive; and various musical artefacts exist from Mycenaean (c1550–1100 bce) and Iron Age and Early Geometric (1100–800 bce) cultures. While this iconographic evidence is valuable, the terminus a quo normally envisioned by the phrase ‘ancient Greek’ is the so-called Archaic period, which is generally taken as referring to the Greek culture of the 8th to 6th centuries bce. The terminus ante quem is more difficult to define because of the vitality of Greek culture, but for the purposes of this article it will be taken as the middle of the 5th century ce.
Within this extended period, a number of different regions contributed to a culture now commonly considered ‘Greek’. Broadly speaking, ancient Greek musical culture was centred in the area of modern Greece (including the Peloponnese); Crete; to the north, the southern regions of Albania, the former Yugoslavia and Bulgaria; to the west, the southern regions of the Italian peninsula; to the east, Asia Minor; and to the south, the northern regions of the African coast (especially in the area of Libya and Egypt). This area includes peoples and regions frequently noted in early literary sources: peoples such as the Dorians, Ionians, Aeolians, Achaeans, Lydians, Phrygians, Thracians, Macedonians, Libyans and Egyptians; and regions such as Boeotia, Euboea, Aetolia, Attica, Achaea, Argolis, Laconia, Thessalia, Calabria and Lucania.

~~~~~~~~

Λέξεις κλειδιά

Cycladic sculpture of musicians
Keros
Thera
Naxos
Peloponnese
Crete
Albania,
Yugoslavia
Bulgaria
Italian peninsula
Asia Minor
African coast
Libya
Egyp
Dorians
Ionians
Aeolians
Achaeans
Lydians
Phrygians
Thracians
Macedonians
Libyans
Boeotia
Euboea
Aetolia
Attica
Achaea
Argolis
Laconia
Thessalia
Calabria Lucania

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Cycladic sculpture of musicians, belonging to the period 2700–2100 bce
Minoan period (c2300–1100 bce)
Mycenaean (c1550–1100 bce)
Iron Age
Early Geometric (1100–800 bce)
Archaic period
 

Zambelis Spyros

Παλαιό Μέλος
Musical life in ancient Greece.
A history, in the modern sense, of ancient Greek music cannot be written because the surviving texts are insufficiently precise in matters of chronology, biography, attribution and even factual detail. Ostensibly historical treatments (by such authors as Alexander, Aristoxenus, Glaucus of Rhegium and Heraclides Ponticus) are cited and excerpted or paraphrased in Pseudo-Plutarch's On Music (Peri mousikēs), but the early treatments themselves do not survive. As noted above (§2), other literary sources provide information about musical matters, but their approaches tend to be technical, antiquarian or museographic rather than historical. It is possible to extract from the sources a considerable picture of ancient Greek music and musical life, but this picture must remain chronologically and historically ambiguous.
The Greeks developed specific musical forms for a wide range of occasions. Encountered in the literary sources are examples of hymns, dithyrambs, wedding songs, threnodies, drinking-songs, love songs, work songs and many other types. Although the music (in the modern sense) for these compositions no longer survives, with the exception of the musical fragments, the texts themselves provide significant evidence about form, structure and rhythm, and they also frequently describe music-making.
The term ‘composition’ should not be misunderstood to imply only a piece of music represented in musical notation. While such compositions of ancient Greek music do exist, pieces of music were also transmitted aurally and performed over the years by many different persons, doubtless with individual variations. On the other hand, some compositions apparently remained individual creations, no longer performed but still recalled by later Greek writers in descriptive terms that conveyed important and influential features of the work.
In the earliest traditions music was performed by a solo singer or chorus with and without instrumental accompaniment. Scenes of music-making already appear in the ‘Shield of Achilles’ (Iliad, xviii.478–607) and elsewhere in the Iliad; the Odyssey incorporates both Phemius and Demodocus, two of the most renowned traditional epic singers (aoidoi or oidoi), as strategic characters within the epic. It is uncertain whether the Iliad and the Odyssey were sung or recited, but extended musical forms – both solo and choral – certainly existed. Purely instrumental music was also popular. Beginning in the 6th century bce, virtuosity and innovation became more prominent in instrumental music, which in turn encouraged complexity in the other musical forms. Conservative poets and philosophers deplored the violation of earlier traditions, but the new styles flourished. Remarkable descriptions of some famous compositions survive, including the Pythic Nomos, a composition for the aulos recalled by Strabo (fl c 1st century bce–1st century ce) in the Geography (ix.3.10; cf Pollux, Onomasticon, iv.78, 84). The composition is not preserved, but similar types of extended and vivid imitative pieces exist in other folk traditions, which may provide some idea of the remarkable effects that could have been used in the Pythic Nomos.
Music in this sense of a performing art was called melos. A distinction was made between melos in general, which might be no more than an instrumental piece or a simple song, and perfect melos (teleion melos; cf Aristides Quintilianus, On Music, i.4), which consisted not only of the melody and the text (including its inherent elements of rhythm and diction) but also highly stylized dance movement. Melic composition (melopoiïa) together with rhythmic composition (rhuthmopoiïa) was the process of selecting and applying the various components of melos and rhythm to create a complete composition (see §6(iii) (g) below). Melic composition is subdivided by Aristides Quintilianus (On Music, i.12) into three classes – dithyrambic, nomic and tragic – parallel to his three classes of rhythmic composition (On Music, i.19) – systaltic, diastaltic and hesychastic. In addition, the three broad classes of melic composition may contain various subclasses, such as erotic, comic and panegyric. By these classifications Aristides Quintilianus would seem to be referring to music written in honour of Dionysus (dithyrambic) or Apollo (nomic) or for the tragedy. Any piece of music might be elevating (diastaltic), depressing (systaltic), or soothing (hesychastic), as appropriate (similar definitions are provided in Cleonides' Harmonic Introduction, 13).
Although the treatise of Aristides Quintilianus is rather late, its system of classification accords with the statements of earlier writers, and there can be little question that from a very early period the Greeks had developed a sophisticated musical typology. Forms might be typified by subject matter, rhythm and metre, large-scale structure, and so on. Plato's Athenian Stranger (Laws, iii, 700a8–e4) observes that the types were once distinct: a hymn would not be confused with a dirge, dithyramb or paean. Nevertheless, Plato also clearly implies that this distinction was beginning to be lost by the mid-4th century bce. A similar point is made in his Republic (iv, 424b5–c6), where Socrates argues against innovations in music because they threaten the fundamental structure of the state: ‘One must be cautious about changing to a new type of music as this risks a change in the whole. The modes [tropoi] of music are never moved without movement of the greatest constitutional laws’. Plato's remarks underscore the fact that the practical manifestations of music form only one part of the Greek concept of mousikē: music occupied a prominent place in everyday life not only because it was amusing and socially valuable but also because it embodied universal principles and was a vehicle for higher understanding.
Writers such as Plato restricted themselves to relatively general descriptions of musical types, but fuller typologies are preserved in the Sophists at Dinner (c200 ce) of Athenaeus and the Bibliotheca (cmid-9th century ce) of Photius, sources that tend, by their nature, to be lexicographic or museographic. Section 239 of the Bibliotheca, which preserves a summary of the Useful Knowledge (Chrestomathia) of Proclus (410/12–85 ce), provides a description of various musical types. After distinguishing between music intended for the gods and music intended for human activity, Proclus lists the types associated with each classification: For the gods: hymn, prosodion, paean, dithyramb, nomos, adonidia, iobakchos and hyporcheme
For humans: encomion, epinikion, skolion, erotica, epithalamia, hymenaios, sillos, threnos and epikedeion
For the gods and humans: partheneion, daphnephorika, tripodephorika, oschophorika and eutika.
It is impossible to know whether this particular typology would have been shared by earlier Greek writers, but it is clear that the Greeks were conscious of specific musical types and their distinctions. Proclus's classification and typology supply a useful model for examining each form (see Dithyramb; Encomium; Hymenaios; Hymn, §I; Kōmos; Nenia; Nomos; Paean; Partheneia; Prosodion; Skolion; Thrēnos; and Tragōidia).
Although a complete picture of the musico-poetic types remains elusive, enough detail survives in the texts, early commentaries, iconography and notated musical fragments to reveal considerable musical sophistication, variety and vitality. Grander and more complex types such as the hymn, paean, prosodion and dithyramb played important roles in religious and civic life. The nomos, originally a form associated with venerable tradition, became the particular vehicle for musical innovation and the development of the virtuoso. The epinikion provided a form in which important personal and human victories could be memorialized to inspire future generations. In the dithyramb, hyporcheme and partheneion, the relationship of dance and music was especially prominent, but the most complete union of music, text, movement and costume was developed in the drama, which formed a centrepiece of the civic and religious festivals of the Greeks. Likewise, everyday social life was supported by wedding and funeral music, love songs, work songs, banquet songs, and so on. In each piece, whether formal and complex or simple and folklike, musicians drew on a wealth of tradition, a powerful and innately sonorous language, and virtually limitless combinations of rhythms, metres, tonoi, inflections of melodic scale, gesture and dance, some of which are described in the technical treatises (see §6(iii) below).

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Λέξεις κλειδιά

chronology
biography
Alexander
Aristoxenus
Glaucus of Rhegium
Heraclides Ponticus
Pseudo-Plutarch's On Music (Peri mousikēs)
literary sources
musical matters
technical
antiquarian
museographic
historical
picture
musical forms
hymns
dithyrambs
wedding songs
threnodies
drinking-songs
love songs
work songs
musical fragments
musical notation
earliest traditions music
performed
solo singer
chorus
instrumental accompanimen
‘Shield of Achilles’ (Iliad, xviii.478–607)
Iliad
Odyssey
Phemius
Demodocus
epic singers (aoidoi or oidoi)
solo
choral
instrumental music
popular
virtuosity
innovation
Conservative poets
philosophers
Pythic Nomos
aulos
Strabo (fl c 1st century bce–1st century ce) in the Geography
Pollux, Onomasticon, iv.78, 84
Pythic Nomos.

performing art
melos.
instrumental piece
simple song
perfect melos (teleion melos; cf Aristides Quintilianus, On Music, i.4),
dance
Melic composition (melopoiïa)
rhythmic composition (rhuthmopoiïa)
Aristides Quintilianus (On Music, i.12)
dithyrambic
nomic
tragic
systaltic
diastaltic
hesychastic
erotic
comic
panegyric
Aristides Quintilianus
Dionysus (dithyrambic)
Apollo (nomic)
tragedy
Cleonides' Harmonic Introduction, 13
rhythm and metre
large-scale structure
Plato's Athenian Stranger (Laws, iii, 700a8–e4)
hymn
dirge
dithyramb
paean
modes [tropoi]
Athenaeus
Bibliotheca (cmid-9th century ce) of Photius,
lexicographic
museographic
(Chrestomathia) of Proclus (410/12–85 ce)
hymn
prosodion
paean
dithyramb
nomos
adonidia
iobakchos
hyporcheme
encomion
epinikion
skolion
erotica
epithalamia
hymenaios
sillos
threnos
epikedeion
partheneion
daphnephorika
tripodephorika
oschophorika
eutika.
Proclus
Dithyramb
Encomium
Hymenaios
Hymn
Kōmos
Nenia
Nomos
Paean
Partheneia
Prosodion
Skolion
Thrēnos
Tragōidia
iconography
notated musical fragments
rhythms
metres
tonoi
inflections of melodic scale
gesture and dance
 
Top